Assembling the Squadron! All Star Squadron 1 Review

 

Rich Buckler's cover is just amazing. Dr. Mid-Nite, Hawkman, and The Atom pouring over photographs of Golden-Age Mystery Men. The cover question "Who Will Be the Heroes of the All-Star Squadron"? Pause for just a moment and consider... "mystery men" and "mystery women" actually posing for photographs, like Hollywood celebrities of the day! Between Hawkman and The Atom is a photograph of The Golden-Age Batman and Robin. These are not newspaper photographs. These are portraits. Posed portraits. In the foreground is a posed portrait of The Spectre. Now, granted, it is possible that a shutterbug might catch one of these colorful figures off-guard. All of the photos on the cover feature the heroes smiling at the camera. Even The Dynamic Duo seem to be caught in a pose, although whether they're smiling is hard to tell. This is going to be a fun book to read, simply because no matter what happens inside, no matter how serious, dramatic or Earth-shattering, the heroes will face it with a positive "can-do" attitude. These heroes will face the hard knocks and shrug each one off with a wink and a smile! These are not angsty, navel-gazing costumed vigilantes... except for Vigilante.

Roy Thomas' "The World on Fire!" opens with Hawkman returning to the Justice Society of America headquarters, where he runs afoul of - - Plastic Man!? A quick recap recounts Solomon Grundy overpowering The Flash, Green Lantern and Wonder Woman; Professor Zodiak capturing The World's Finest team of Batman and Robin along with Superman; Wotan capturing Dr. Fate and The Spectre; and Sky Pirate capturing Johnny Thunder and Thunderbolt along with The Sandman and Starman! Hawkman, Dr. Mid-Nite and The Atom faced and bested The Monster! On their way to Washington, Hawkman and Plastic Man encounter King Bee! They quickly best him and his winged henchman!

Elsewhere, Sir Justin, The Shining Knight and Danette Reilly are captured by Per Degaton and his crew!

All these events lead up to the Japanese attack on Pearl Harbor.

At the White House, Hawkman and Plastic Man are joined by Robotman, The Atom, Dr. Mid-Nite, Johnny Quick and Liberty Belle! They are commissioned as The All-Star Squadron and head to San Francisco to head off saboteurs and ultimately stop Degaton!

Buckler and Ordway's art is just simply Golden-Age eye-candy. On newsprint, John Costanza's lettering is somewhat muddy and blurred. Carl Gafford's coloring is top-notch. Len Wein guides creators Roy Thomas and Buckler to a thrilling, enjoyable story.

The Greatest Generation saving the world earns five stars.

The Thrilling Action-Packed Conclusion; JSA: All Stars 8 Review

If DC Comics is about anything, it is about "legacy". The idea that the mantle, the torch is passed down. Jay Garrick, Alan Scott and Carter Hall were heroes of the Golden-Age of Comics. The Flash, Green Lantern and Hawkman. When the Silver-Age was launched, Barry Allen, Hal Jordan and Katar Hol took up the mantle and carried the baton. These three, along with Ted Grant were captured by Legacy first, because they don't have a counterpart in the Justice Society. Their legacy is with the Justice League. Hawkgirl, Dr. Fate, Stargirl, Hourman, Dr. Mid-Nite, and Mr. Terrific are all legacy heroes. They've taken on the mantle and picked up the baton from previous heroes.

So it was that The Spectre told them to prepare and brace themselves to go on the rescue mission. What seems off is that it's obvious that it's not really The Spectre. He's Legacy's captive as well. So, it just seems out of place he would be presenting and narrating each hero's personal journey. 

When the Justice Society regroup at their New York City brownstone headquarters, The Spectre reappears. Just as the team is piecing together important clues. The Spectre stands revealed by Dr. Fate as Legacy, and he whisks them off to another realm, where they find their teammates. Fate and Hawkgirl are able to free the real Spectre, who in turn reveals Legacy's more true identity - The Wizard! In the ensuing battle, he is fighting for survival. Gone and forgotten are the Injustice Gang. Where are they now? 

The Spectre ends the conflict by sending The Wizard to hades, where he will be confronted by the sister he murdered. Condemnation or retribution. Jay, Alan, Carter and Ted are troubled by this fiery fury. Yet they are heartened that they can be inspired by this new generation in turn as they pass on inspiration.

As enjoyable as it is, it's all sort of thin and flimsy. The Wizard's plot kind of floppy. While the pacing of the story is smooth, the motivation seems somewhat forced. It has to happen because it has to happen! Taken separately and individually, the issues are enjoyable, unfortunately they don't really stack up all that well as a whole. Your mileage may vary on that.

JSA: All Stars 8, "And Justice For All" earns three stars.